A Review: Can You Hear the Nightbird Call? by Anita Rau Badami

***

A Review:

Can You Hear the Nightbird Call?

By Anita Rau Badami

12.10.2011

By Zara D. Garcia-Alvarez / @ZaraAlexis

***

Category: Fiction

Author: Anita Rau Badami

Format: Hardcover, 432 pages

Publisher: Knopf Canada

ISBN: 978-0676976045

Pub Date: September 5, 2006

***

What began as a somewhat hopeful book, quickly and devastatingly spiralled into a travesty. I was left with the shock of death and loss for all characters and after reading the novel I was angry at its historical injustices.

At the same time, I regretted investing emotional attachments to characters that were deeply flawed. My sense of the novel’s downfall lay at the heart of its characters’ weakness to pride.

Harjot Singh is listless and “disappears” long before he actually decides to leave his family, his pride wounded because he was unable to freely land ashore once he arrived to Vancouver by ship on the Komagata Maru.

His daughter, Sharanjeet (Bibi-ji) Kaur, privately resents her station in life and her duties, unhappy to be obedient to her mother or selfless to her sister, Kanwar. This attitude is not entirely due to her spoiled upbringing, but rather an internal pride, vanity, and materialistic ambition that drives her to first steal her sister’s marriage prospect, Khushwant (Pa-ji) Singh from her sister, and then eventually her niece’s own son, Jasbeer.

Leela (Shastri) Bhat is ostracized by her grandmother, Akka, and her father’s relatives because she is considered a “half-breed,” a daughter of a Punjab, Hari Shastri, and an English woman, Rosa Schweers. Rather than accept her genetic fate and cultural liminality, she loathes her own grey eyes, fair skin, and “White” culture. Instead she prides herself in becoming the wife of a prosperous and prestigious man, Balachandra (Balu) Bhat, who comes from a well known Punjab family and high caste, and submerges herself into adhering to traditional Indian practices. Leela, opposite of Bibi-ji, resents being pulled from her home in India to Vancouver, fearful of becoming, yet again, nameless. Though she suffered racial cruelty from her Indian grandmother, she fails to accept her son’s choice in marriage to an English woman.

These and other characters provide a backdrop to the cruelty and harshness of the warring factions of the Hindu, Muslim, and Sikh people, which led to The Partition of India (with its Hindu majority) and Pakistan (with its Muslim majority). Violent acts of brutality by government and militant groups climaxed to the eventual killings of pilgrims at the Golden Temple. This act in itself prompted the assassination of Prime Minister, Indira Ghandi, which then led to vengeful killings of Sikhs throughout India. And a year later, Air India Flight 182 is bombed, killing 329 people on board from Canada over the Atlantic Ocean.

Perhaps it is Badami’s intent to situate her characters at the “wrong time in the wrong place,” but also to propel them forward into devastation and loss due to wrong choices, which stem from deeply rooted pride and discord.

The book is without resolution, but is a haunting reminder of the brutality and injustice of war, the interconnectedness between people, their actions, and their consequences, and the cost of life for the sake of land, name, autonomy, and religious freedom, where moderation seems to be the best answer though it is rarely used.

It is a novel of extremes, but then, extremity is at the heart of this book’s subject, while a lesson of temperance is still yet to be learned.

***

Zara’s Rating

 

***

Book Review: Unaccustomed Earth by Jhumpa Lahiri

Book Review:

Unaccustomed Earth by Jhumpa Lahiri

12.10.2011

By Zara D. Garcia-Alvarez / @ZaraAlexis

***

Category: Fiction

Author: Jhumpra Lahiri

Format: Hardcover, 352 pages

Publisher: Knopf Canada

ISBN: 978-0676979343

Pub Date: April 1, 2008

***

Lahiri depicts the restraint of her characters perfectly and reveals to us private desires that cause conflict with the traditions and expectations of Indian cultural and societal norms. But, by doing so, she redefines love and the inevitability of the sorrow it sometimes carries. She is a queen of dichotomy. Though her characters have inner strength that persists and drives them further into their stories, their strengths are also what make them the victims of their own helplessness.

From Ruma’s father in his inability to share with his daughter, the acknowledgement of his feelings for another woman after the death of his wife. To Ruma, who is unable to recover from her mother’s death, only to cope by denying herself a successful career and a rich relationship with her husband and son. The restraint in the relationship between “Baba” and Ruma contain within its silences and tension, a depth of love and feeling that can only be understood by grief, denial, and the need to protect those that are loved.

The story of Pranab Chakraborty and Boudi speaks of an unrequited love that evolves within the boundaries of family friendship, compatibility, and all that is lacking in another marriage. It is a tight-lipped, repressed, and torturous story of one who carries the burden of secret love, while the other remains oblivious to his lover’s personal sacrifice and loss.

Amit and Megan share the reality of a marriage that has reached its low season dented by babies and the monotony of routine. People from their pasts can resurrect old feelings, yet reassure us as readers that passion can still spring up from the loyalty and trust found in married love.

Sudha and Rahul speak of weakened family ties because of the powerful stronghold of addiction and the loss of relationship and trust that occurs when someone is strangled by the compulsion of vices and old stereotypes.

In the story of Sang, Paul, Farsouk, and Deidre, there is truth in the tangles of love, desire, and manipulation. It reflects the compulsions we sometimes have against our better judgement and the inability to see clearly when we feel we are in love.

Hema and Kaushik share with us two opposing lives, which are drawn to each other by family ties and later by circumstance or fate. The drama of their passion and love, though restrained by the reality of other entanglements, seem inevitable and doomed to suffer a sad demise.

Overall, I found the book, Unaccustomed Earth to be filled with good stories, though desolate and bleak. I was inspired by love, but sometimes disappointed by the failings of the characters and their outcome.

Still, after reading the book, I yearned for the stories to continue; for the characters to continue on in their vignettes, if not to provide a glimpse to a more resilient hope of something better for the characters themselves, but also an affirmation that love and lovers actually do “conquer all.”

Compared to Lahiri’s other works, this collection is darker and more sombre in its tone. Your heart will break in reading it, but insist in some way that it must be so.

***

Zara’s Rating

***

Book Review: The Birth House by Ami McKay

Book Review:

The Birth House by Ami McKay

12.10.2011

By Zara Alexis D. Garcia-Alvarez / @ZaraAlexis

 

***

Category: Fiction

Author: Ami McKay

Format: Hardcover, 400 pages

Publisher: Knopf Canada

ISBN: 978-0676977721

Pub Date: February 16, 2006

***

The story is not so much a story about birthing as it is one of the evolution of becoming re-born. There is character development—and then there are characters that already have everything they need to engage you with ease, curiosity, nostalgia, and a little spunk.

This book is about a number of struggles. A tension between choosing and ultimately accepting the dichotomies of our lives: what it means to be a woman embedded in the rural roots of the Bay of Fundy, Maritimes and what it could mean to be a woman witnessing the narrow streets filled with heavy brick buildings of a modernizing city called Boston; to the struggle of keeping the sentimentality, spirituality, and instinctive old wisdom of traditional midwifery versus the collision it faces with the sterility of new and upcoming science, technology, and modern medicine.

This is a story about women, for women—the empowerment needed to realize autonomy over choices, especially if those choices have to do with a woman’s body—her fertility, her pregnancy, her labour, her sex life, and the secrets of her desires.

It’s also about community, home, and the special relationship women can and do have with one another, exclusive of their partners, or the male-dominated assumptions that can be imposed upon them, and the circumstances of a changing world.

In the face of fierce opposition, women in this novel bond, grow, and struggle together as fiercely as labour itself, to not reclaim themselves—but to proclaim themselves according to an identity that is acceptable to each of them on a personal level.

It’s a tribute to the female struggle and the glorious gift we have been given as women: the tolerance and endurance to suffer pain and tragedy in order to make a life, carry it, save it, and also potentially live it: generation by generation; one moon; one prayer; one stitch, and one choice at a time.

A fierce and lovely novel about womanhood, motherhood, companionship, and birthing.

***

Zara’s Rating

***

Have you ever given birth to a child?

What do you find the most difficult about labour?

In what ways can you empower yourself and others through the birthing process?

***

A Review: Memories of My Melancholy Whores by Gabriel Garcia-Marquez

A Review:

Memories of My Melancholy Whores

By Gabriel Garcia-Marquez

12.09.2011

By Zara D. Garcia-Alvarez / @ZaraAlexis

***

Category: Fiction

Author: Gabriel Garcia-Marquez

Format: Hardcover, 128 pages

Publisher: Knopf Canada

ISBN: 978-1400044603

Pub Date: October 25, 2005

***

Don’t be misled by the number of pages—though it’s a short book, its rich with tormented love, drama, and passion. The character, himself, is multi-layered, driven by nostalgia, dignity, indulgence and denial. He is tormented with lust, illusion, love, repression and longing. His desire is fuelled by regret.

It’s a mouthful of a book within so few pages. The writing has a poetic cadence without a superficiality that needs to impress. The language and internal dialogue is read with such ease, such passion is believable and even encouraged. The main character is obviously flawed, and loss, inevitable. Yet, if you’re a romantic, even a remotely secret one, you’ll enjoy this passionate novella.

(Might I suggest you read this by candlelight, a cozy blanket, and a fine red wine?)

***

Zara’s Rating

***

A Review: The Cellist of Sarajevo by Steven Galloway

A Review:

The Cellist of Sarajevo by Steven Galloway

12.09.2012

By Zara D. Garcia-Alvarez / @ZaraAlexis

***

Category: Fiction

Author: Steven Galloway

Format: Hardcover, 272 pages

Publisher: Knopf Canada

ISBN: 978-0-307-39703-4

Pub Date: April 8, 2008

***

The Cellist of Sarajevo is a stark, microcosmic account of the effects of war on four main characters:

The Cellist who is compelled to play the cello for 22 days to commemorate the death of 22 people who died by a shelling while waiting in line at a bakery for a loaf of bread.

A female sniper by the name of “Arrow,” who has accurate precision and a high volume of successful kills. Arrow normally acts independently choosing her targets at will, but is later assigned to defend the cellist from any potential attacks. Though extremely talented, the course of her actions lead her to a duplicate identity and a hard, cold, ambivalence.

Kenan is a family man, a husband and a father to two children. He is over-burdened by the fear he holds in the responsibility of providing basic needs for his family and must live out a somewhat duplicate identity, concealing his fear every time he must leave his home. He travels a day’s worth to fetch water in the few bottles he must reuse and carry on his own. He fears the death he potentially faces with each step he makes on his journey and what may happen to his family if he does not return.

Dragan is a husband and a father to a son who were fortunate enough to flee to Italy during the war. Dragan is left behind in Sarajevo, unknown to be dead or alive. He works at a local bakery that allows him the privilege to daily bread and food in the kitchen should he be able to make it to work. The war hardens Dragan’s sensibility and drives him to hopeless pessimism, which causes him anxiety and prevents him from contact with people of his past to strangers that he may meet on the street.

The novel began slowly in its plain narrative, but I believe the minimalism of the language was perhaps intentional to emphasize the stark nature of war. The tone, sombre and grey, and its pathetic fallacy speaks to the affect of war on innocent civilians.

The fact that the story focused on four separate characters brought home the reality of how war can affect people differently and yet just as tragically. But I was relieved at the redemption found for each character in their slow, yet purposeful evolution.

Dragan was able to reconcile his anxiety in meeting his past by running into Emina, a woman who he and his wife had known before the war. They come in contact before considering crossing the street, which in wartime is as dangerous as entering a minefield. They exchange a few words and Dragan discovers that Emina is risking her life to deliver expired medication to a stranger and to also listen to the local yet, famous cellist play the cello. Dragan resists her reasoning in doing this, but regrets being harsh with her. He only realizes his error in closing himself off to people and the world when Emina crosses the street and gets shot. Dragan is stunned into immobility. Unlike others who choose to risk their lives by helping her come across the street to relative safety and to whisk her off to a hospital for medical attention, Dragan is frozen in his fear, helplessness, and disbelief. He does, however, come to terms with this and compensates by eventually helping an already dead man move out of harm’s way and out from the eyes of the media. Dragan decides then that he will be one of the few left to help rebuild the Sarajevo that he remembers and assertively walks across the street in answer to the “men in the hills” by displaying his decision to no longer live under a regime of oppression and fear despite the war that continues to diminish the lives of the Sarajevan people. This decision is cemented by his courteous and jovial greeting, “Good afternoon” to a stranger passing him by in the street, when obviously the afternoon is neither good, but the greeting empathetic and necessary.

Kenan who cries out in exasperation by the exhaustion and toll it has taken on him to travel, search out, and obtain water for his family—not a simple task by any means when the brewery in which he gets his water is attacked by bombing and he is forced to witness violence, mayhem, and death—decides for himself that he will not falter to pessimism and hopelessness as embodied in Mrs. Ristovski’s character, by returning on another trip to reclaim the bottles of water for his neighbour that he had angrily left behind. I, myself, would have chosen to leave the bottles where they were left considering how terrible and abrasive Mrs. Ristovski’s character is to Dragan personally, but for drama’s sake and good storytelling, this act shows not only Kenan’s growth as a character, but also the magnitude in which his sacrifice is made. Yes, he could get killed on the way to the bridge by exposing himself to indiscriminate snipers from the opposing side. Yes, he witnesses the treachery of blood, death, and helplessness in an afternoon bombing. Yes, he’s exhausted beyond measure. And yes, Mrs. Ristovski’s nature does not deserve kindness, let alone sacrifice. But Kenan returns to find the bottles of water he left behind because he would rather choose to live with integrity rather than fear.

Arrow, who decides to allow Sarajevan guerrillas to locate and assassinate her even though she has the ability to prevent this from happening, shows her willingness to “kill” the character she had become. This death is a timely and justified one, perhaps not only as atonement for her own killing crimes, but also as an opportunity for her to reclaim herself as the person she used to be before the war, before she had become a sniper, and before she changed her named. She utters in willingness her true name, “I am Alisa,” as a testimony and epitaph of who she chooses to be at the end of her life.

The cellist, not only as a man who brought locals together in unification to mourn 22 dead civilians for 22 days, also solidified for himself an answer in the madness of war. He played his cello at the risk of his own life as a commemoration of the deaths that took place, but also played his cello as a heroic and therapeutic answer to his own sorrow and grief about the war on Sarajevo in general. He does not speak in the novel, a mute character who, but only plays a sad rendition of a score that was historically “pieced” together from rubble – from nothing. This act is not only beautiful and bittersweet, but a central focus to the hope and resistance shown by a people who must resign to the facets of a war ridden, occupied Sarajevo. The task is complete and this sense of completion gives the cellist and its listeners, its interactive audience, a voice without speaking and a resolution to some form of peace and reconciliation to what has happened and what civilians hope for the future.

Though the book is dark, sombre, tragic, and stark – it does not leave you in the hole that was birthed by the shelling of war. It does in its own slow, methodical, evolution give rise to a people in how they are able to overcome personal struggle against the terror of nameless death and the dying of infrastructure, their culture, and their home.

***

Zara’s Rating

***